Approve

For HR administrators

The studio runs in Arabic. Screen labels are shown below in Arabic, with an English gloss in brackets, so you can find them on screen. Your documents can be in English; quotes keep the source wording.

الاعتماد (Approve) is the step where you confirm the alternative you chose in Alternatives and approve it. It is a light screen: what you are approving on one side, and the confirmation on the other. النموذج المعتمد (Approved) then holds the decision: the approved structure, the decision record and a PDF report. You are the one who approves. The step shows the strip «مسودات مولّدة بالذكاء الاصطناعي · أنت من يعتمد» (AI-generated drafts · you approve).

The judging happens before this step. Reading, scoring, comparing and Score all are in Alternatives; this step does not rank anything on screen. The decision record and the PDF still hold the ranking, how stable it is, and the traceability against the directions: the server computes them from the locked criteria and the scores at the moment you approve, and freezes them in the record.

Who can do what

ActionPermission
Open the step, read the summary and the warnings, open the Approved step and its decision record, download the PDFView (operating_model.view)
اعتمد (Approve) and أعد فتح القرار… (Reopen the decision…)Approve and reopen the operating model decision (operating_model.decision.approve)

Workspace Admin always has the approve permission, and it is seeded alongside the permission to lock criteria. Every role that already held Lock and unlock criteria (operating_model.frame.lock) was given it too. You can grant it to any other role under Settings → Users & roles → Roles. It is a separate permission so a workspace can let analysts edit alternatives without letting them make the final decision. Without it, the approve button is disabled, and its tooltip says «ليست لديك صلاحية اعتماد قرار النموذج التشغيلي» (You do not have permission to approve the operating model decision). See Overview.

In an archived project the step is read-only and approving and reopening are refused.

Before you approve

The step needs two things. If the criteria are not locked it says «اقفل المعايير والأوزان أولاً» (Lock the criteria & weights first) and links to Directions & criteria. If the project has no alternatives it says «ولّد البدائل أولاً» (Generate alternatives first). If the criteria are open for editing while an earlier version is locked, the step says so, and you can still approve, with a warning.

Which alternative

You arrive from Alternatives with اختر هذا للاعتماد (Choose for approval) or متابعة إلى الاعتماد (Continue to approval), and the alternative is the one in the page address (?alt=…). Nothing is chosen for you: there is no default, not even the best-scored one. If you open the step without one, the summary column is a picker, اختر بديلًا… (Choose an alternative…), listing every alternative of every generation, with a link اختر بديلًا من خطوة البدائل (Choose an alternative from the Alternatives step). Approve stays disabled until one is chosen.

What you are approving

The summary shows the chosen alternative: its letter, consultant and generation, its full title, its version, the rule badge, the weighted score, the org chart and the summary text (longer summaries fold behind اعرض المزيد, Show more). غيّر (Change) takes you back to Alternatives with this alternative selected. If you change your mind there and save a new version, this screen asks you to review the new one (see below).

The confirmation

Beside the summary, the confirmation panel holds everything the old approve dialog held, inline:

  1. What you are approving: the alternative, its version, the rule badge and its weighted score. If it is not among the ranked alternatives, it says غير مرتّب (Not ranked) with the reason, for example it is not scored yet or scored on an earlier criteria version.
  2. التنبيهات (Warnings), computed by the server from stored data. No warning blocks approval; all of them are saved with the decision.
WarningWhen
غير مرتّب (Not ranked)The alternative is unscored, scored on older criteria or on an older version, or breaks the rules, with the reason
يخالف القواعد (Breaks the rules)The version has rule findings
المعايير مفتوحة للتعديل الآن (The criteria are open for editing now)The criteria are unlocked. The decision uses the locked version, and approving is allowed with this warning
تغيّرت المدخلات بعد إنشاء هذا الإصدار (Inputs changed since this version was created)The inputs changed after the version
تغيّرت المعايير بعد تقييمه (Criteria changed since it was scored)The score is on an older criteria version
توجه عالي الأولوية غير مغطّى (A high-priority direction is not covered)A direction with the highest priority is not covered by the alternative, or only claimed
ادعاء غير متحقق منه (An unverified claim)The count of claims without evidence
  1. لماذا تعتمده رغم مخالفات القواعد؟ (Why approve it despite the rule breaches?) appears only when the version breaks rules, and a reason is required (اكتب السبب لتعتمد بديلًا يخالف القواعد). It is saved with the decision and printed in the report.
  2. البدائل الأخرى (Other alternatives), optional and folded: one line per alternative you did not choose, لماذا لم تختر [B]؟ (Why did you not choose [B]?).
  3. القوى العاملة (Workforce): the line «يبدأ الاعتماد ربط مكتبة التحجيم بهذا الهيكل مرة واحدة لحساب متطلبات القوى العاملة» (Approving starts mapping the sizing library to this structure, once, to compute the workforce requirements), with the time estimate of that run, or «التقدير غير متاح» (Estimate unavailable) when the AI service is offline. Approval is never blocked by the estimate.
  4. The checkbox راجعتُ هذا البديل ومصادره (I reviewed this alternative and its sources) and اعتمد (Approve). Approve stays disabled until the box is ticked.

When a decision is already active, the panel shows it («معتمد: …», Approved: …) with افتح النموذج المعتمد (Open the approved model) instead, and approving is disabled with «أعد فتح القرار أولًا» (Reopen the decision first).

The step's pinned action bar at the bottom of the screen shows the alternative you are about to approve (or the active approval once there is one), with السابق: البدائل (Previous: Alternatives). Once an alternative is approved, التالي: النموذج المعتمد (Next: Approved) leads on.

Approving is refused when:

  • no criteria are locked (the step already tells you to lock them first). With the criteria unlocked for editing but an earlier locked version in place, approving is allowed, with a warning;
  • the alternative changed while you were reviewing: someone saved a new version. The panel says «تغيّر البديل أثناء المراجعة — راجع النسخة الجديدة» (The alternative changed during the review — review the new version) and reloads the new version; nothing is recorded;
  • a decision is already active: «يوجد قرار معتمد في هذا المشروع؛ أعد فتحه أولًا». A double click or two people approving at the same moment record exactly one decision;
  • the alternative has no draft (a failed consultant): «لا مسودة لهذا البديل لاعتمادها».

The server computes the warnings and the frozen record itself; it never trusts the numbers on your screen. Approving is recorded in the Audit log as your action.

The Approved step

النموذج المعتمد (Approved) shows the active decision: who approved it and when (in Hijri and Gregorian dates), and the strip «مسودات مولّدة بالذكاء الاصطناعي · أنت من يعتمد». Until there is a decision it says «لا هيكل معتمد بعد» (No approved structure yet) and links to Approve.

  • الهيكل المعتمد (The approved structure): the version you approved, read-only, in the same tabs as the Alternatives pane: structure, rationale and sources, change from today, and rules and checks.
  • سجل القرار (The decision record), frozen at approval. It does not change when criteria, inputs or scores change later. It holds the warnings you accepted and the rule-breach reason, the locked weights, the ranking and its stability as they were, the traceability against the directions (all computed by the server when you approved), the other alternatives and why they were not chosen, and the edit history up to the approved version, with how many operations came from the AI assistant. It also keeps the evidence behind the claims, so if an input is removed from the project later, the quotes and sources still show here and in the PDF. It also freezes the flow map and the names it uses; a decision approved before this was added shows a note instead of the flow map.
  • A workforce card (متطلبات القوى العاملة) with the plan's status and its main numbers, and a link to the step. See Workforce requirements.
  • نزّل التقرير PDF (Download the PDF report) and أعد فتح القرار… (Reopen the decision…).
  • The step's pinned action bar at the bottom of the screen shows the decision's label and title, نزّل التقرير PDF (Download the PDF report), السابق: الاعتماد (Previous: Approve) and التالي: متطلبات القوى العاملة (Next: Workforce requirements).
  • If the criteria or inputs change after the decision, an alert says so («تغيّرت المعايير بعد هذا القرار», «تغيّرت المدخلات بعد هذا القرار»). Unlocking the criteria for editing already raises the criteria alert, before any re-lock. The decision and its record stay as approved. To build on the change, reopen the decision and review the alternatives again.

The edit lock

While a decision is active, the approved alternative cannot change. تعديل (Edit), save, العودة إلى مسودة الذكاء الاصطناعي (Revert to AI draft), استعد هذا الإصدار (Restore this version) and the AI assistant are disabled with «معتمد — أعد فتح القرار للتعديل» (Approved — reopen the decision to edit), and the server refuses them too. What still works: reading in the Alternatives pane, compare, the history, حفظ كبديل جديد (Save as a new alternative) (the copy is a new, unapproved alternative, handy for preparing a change before you reopen), قيّم and أعد التقييم (they add a score and change nothing in the decision), and أعد التشغيل (Run again), which makes a new alternative.

Unlocking or re-locking the criteria and changing inputs stay possible, and do not touch the decision.

Reopening a decision

أعد فتح القرار… (Reopen the decision…) needs the approve permission. The dialog says that the approval is withdrawn and the alternative can be edited again, and takes an optional reason, saved with the old decision and printed in its report. Reopening is recorded in the Audit log. Once reopened, the alternative unlocks, and the project can approve again. Workforce requirements built from the decision are marked سُحبت (Withdrawn) and kept in its history. Seats already sent to Hire stay there.

The reopened decision moves to القرارات السابقة (Past decisions). Each shows who approved it and when, who reopened it, when and why, and can be opened read-only from its frozen record, with its own PDF. Its banner says «قرار سابق — سُحب الاعتماد في [date]» (A past decision — approval withdrawn on [date]).

The PDF report

نزّل التقرير PDF downloads a report in Arabic (right to left), with English quotes kept in English. It is generated on request from the frozen record, so it is the same for everyone and every time. It holds the cover (project, entity, decision date, approver), the summary (the alternative, its rank, score, rule status, the warnings and any rule-breach reason), the structure chart, the change from today, the صلاحيات القرار (Decision rights) section, the rationale with numbered footnotes, the ranking and stability lines, the traceability, the other alternatives and reasons, the edit history, the list of sources (footnote number, input, page, quote), an annex التجارب المماثلة (Similar experiences) listing the briefs the decision used with their state, URLs and retrieval dates (see Similar experiences; decisions made before that step existed have none) and a note on the models used by role. When the decision has a ready (or withdrawn) workforce plan, the report ends with a workforce annex; see Workforce requirements. The strip «مسودات مولّدة بالذكاء الاصطناعي · أنت من يعتمد» is on every page.

  • Decision rights. When the approved alternative reassigns decision rights, the report lists them, grouped by category: the decision and its threshold, من (From), إلى (To) and the reason. They are taken from the rights the alternative was generated against and frozen with the decision, so later changes to your governance inputs do not alter them. The section is left out when the alternative reassigns none. For now the Approved step does not show this section on screen; it is in the PDF.
  • A decision that was reopened carries «سُحب الاعتماد في [date]» (Approval withdrawn on [date]) on every page.
  • Each download is recorded in the Audit log.

Where your data goes

  • Approving, reopening and every PDF download are recorded in the Audit log as your actions.
  • The decision record, the frozen evidence and the PDF stay inside your workspace. The PDF is built on the server and is not sent to an AI model.
  • Nothing in this step changes your Organizational Structure.